The Best Christmas Cookie Recipes For This Holiday Season

It’s the most wonderful time of the year, and that calls for celebration. The holidays are all about coming together and spreading joy, which means you’ll most likely be preparing to have family and friends visiting your home. There are countless holiday entertaining recipes and ideas you can use for inspiration, especially when it comes to the cookies. 

Finding the perfect holiday cookies to make is all part of the fun. So, as you begin your shopping list for Christmas cookies this year, consider trying some of our favorite recipes. We’ve done our homework and come up with some of the best Christmas cookie recipes for this holiday season, and believe us, they won’t disappoint!

10 Tasty Christmas Cookies to Make

There are so many fun Christmas cookie recipes to choose from that it can sometimes be overwhelming narrowing down your options. In light of spreading Christmas cheer, we decided to compile a list of holiday cookie ideas to get you inspired for this season. Whether you’re a chocolate lover or prefer something fruity, it’s up to you to pick the best Christmas cookie recipes you want to whip up this December. 

1. Chewy Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies

If you love the tangy taste of cranberries mixed with buttery goodness and sweet white chocolate, these are the cookies for you. The base is a classic oatmeal cookie that is perfectly complemented by cranberry pieces and white chocolate chunks mixed in. Check out the full recipe for chewy cranberry oatmeal cookies here!

2. Salted Brownie Cookies

These cookies are the definition of sweet and salty. Make one fudgy delight by bringing two delicious desserts together. The crackled outside is topped off with gooey chocolate chips and sea salt flakes, becoming any chocolate lover’s favorite type of Christmas cookie. See the full salted brownie cookie recipe here!

3. Cheesecake-Stuffed Red Velvet Cookies

Get creative with your cookies by adding a surprise in the middle. These moist red velvet cookies are stuffed with cheesecake, so you get a twist with every bite. This is a great dessert that is sure to impress guests, but is fairly simple to make. You can learn how to make these delicious treats by seeing the full recipe for cheesecake stuffed red velvet cookies here!

4. Turtle Cookies

These cookies have it all. A chocolate batter loaded with caramel pieces, pecans, and chocolate chips – it’s hard not to love. They are soft and chewy and will no doubt be the next big hit at your cookie exchange. Simple and quick to make, you can see the full recipe for turtle cookies here, and start baking today!

5. Raspberry Almond Thumbprint Cookies

Enjoy a Christmas classic with these thumbprint cookies. A buttery shortbread base filled with a raspberry jam is the perfect festive treat, not to mention the coating of a sweet almond glaze. You’ll find that these don’t just taste delicious, but they taste like home. Find out more about the full raspberry almond thumbprint cookie recipe here!

6. Gingerbread Kiss Cookies

Take traditional gingerbread cookies to the next level by adding a Hershey kiss to the recipe. A soft gingerbread base is topped off with a festive white chocolate twist Hershey kiss. This recipe is great for turning an old recipe into something new. Easy to make and delicious to eat, check out the full recipe for gingerbread kiss cookies here!

7. Cinnamon Roll Sugar Cookies

It’s hard to go wrong with cinnamon and sugar. Convert a cinnamon roll into a soft sugar cookie. Don’t settle for an average snickerdoodle cookie when you can have these. They look and taste exactly like cinnamon rolls, making them irresistible. Learn how to make them by checking out the full recipe for cinnamon roll sugar cookies here!

8. Lemon Meringue Cookies

These tasty treats are easy to make and will leave anyone who has a sweet tooth satisfied. They are the perfect mixture of tart and sweet. You can’t go wrong with lemon meringue and this cookie gives you the traditional taste in every bite. Check out the full lemon meringue cookie recipe here!

9. Peppermint Chocolate Chip Cookies

Experience the fresh mint taste from a candy cane mixed with chocolatey goodness. If you want to switch up the usual chocolate chip cookie recipe try adding peppermint. These are the perfect festive treats for the holiday season. Soft and chewy these will become your new favorite dessert, making it impossible to just have one. See the full peppermint chocolate chip cookies recipe here to start baking!

10. Cappuccino Swirl Cookies

For all the coffee lovers out there, we have a cookie for you. This unique cookie is coffee-flavored with a hint of Irish cream and a delicious chocolate swirl. It melts in your mouth and even looks impressive, but is actually easy to make. Try something new this Christmas by giving your guests a cookie they won’t forget. Start baking by checking out the full cappuccino swirl cookies recipe here!

Must-Have Ingredients for Christmas Cookies

Every cookie recipe is different, so naturally, the ingredients will vary with each cookie. However, there are some staple items you want to make sure you have before you begin making any type of Christmas cookie. These are the must-haves that are used in almost every recipe. Be prepared for this holiday season by getting some of these popular cookie ingredients ahead of time:

• Flour
• Cornstarch
• Oats
• Baking Soda 
• Baking Powder
• Cream of Tartar
• Spices
• Sugars
• Syrups
• Cream
• Half and Half
• Milk
• Eggs
• Oil
• Butter
• Shortening

Remember, even if you have all of these ingredients in your pantry, you may need to purchase some additional ingredients. Always double-check your recipe to make sure you have everything you need before you begin your baking. If you find yourself in a bind, don’t worry, there are also countless baking substitutions you can use in place of the original ingredient.

Ready to start grocery shopping for this holiday season? Stop by Stauffers of Kissel Hill to see all of the fresh foods we have to offer.